Your own ETF portfolio or a charitable fund: what does the taxman say?

Julian Lindenberg• Updated November 17, 2026

Your own ETF portfolio or a charitable fund: what does the taxman say?

Foto von Vitaly Gariev auf Unsplash

Why donate to a fund that invests in ETFs when you have your own portfolio? You could buy the same portfolio (70% MSCI World ESG, 30% MSCI Emerging Markets ESG) and donate 2% of it every year. Returns, costs and payout rule would be the same. The difference lies with the tax office.

The result: €10,000 over 50 years

Loading component...

After 30 years, around €13,880 has reached the charities through the fund, and around €12,760 through your own portfolio. After 50 years it is €42,830 compared with €36,080. The gap of around €6,750 is caused by tax alone.

Loading component...

The assets themselves also grow faster in the fund, because no tax flows out. Your own portfolio also still carries tax on its capital gains, which would be due on a sale (dashed line).

The three key differences

Returns: tax-free instead of taxed every year

In a private portfolio you pay German flat-rate capital gains tax (Abgeltungsteuer), effectively around 18.5% on every euro of gain for equity ETFs1. This applies even if you never sell: through the advance lump sum (Vorabpauschale) you pay tax every year, around €41 in 2026 on a portfolio worth €10,0001. On top of that comes tax on the gains in the units you sell for your donation. Wealth for the World is a registered charity, and income from managing its assets is tax-free2. Every euro of return stays in the fund and keeps working.

Tax deduction: the whole donation at once instead of 2% a year

You deduct donations at your marginal tax rate: at 42%, you get 42 cents back for every euro you donate. Each year, donations of up to 20% of your income count, and the rest is carried forward to the following years3.

With Wealth for the World, the whole amount is a donation straight away: at 42%, €10,000 saves you up to €4,200 in tax. With your own portfolio, only what you actually donate is deductible, so just over €200 in the first year and a saving of around €90. The capital itself is never deducted.

Reliability: a rule that outlasts you

A private portfolio is part of your estate. Without a will, your heirs decide whether the 2% rule continues, and they pay inheritance tax above the allowances. Gifts to charitable organisations, by contrast, are exempt from inheritance and gift tax4. With Wealth for the World, an institution keeps the payout rule for decades, in crisis years too.

When your own portfolio makes sense

Your own portfolio remains your property. If you are not sure whether you might need the money yourself later, a final donation is the wrong step. For small portfolios whose income stays within the saver's allowance of €1,000, the tax disadvantage hardly matters either1.

What this means for your donation

If you have set aside an amount for good causes for good, it achieves more through Wealth for the World: returns stay tax-free, the donation is deductible straight away, and the rule carries on without you.

Footnotes

  1. etf.capital, "Vorabpauschale 2026: Rechner, Beispiele und der Basiszins von 3,20 %". etf.capital ↩ ↩2 ↩3

  2. Ministry of Finance of Saxony-Anhalt, Vereine und Steuerrecht. mf.sachsen-anhalt.de ↩

  3. § 10b EStG (German Income Tax Act), "Steuerbegünstigte Zwecke". gesetze-im-internet.de ↩

  4. § 13 ErbStG (German Inheritance Tax Act), "Steuerbefreiungen". gesetze-im-internet.de ↩

Related Articles

Loading related articles...